5 Toughest NHL Players to Play Against

Richard M. Coleman
3 min readFeb 1, 2024

Ice hockey is known for its physicality, speed, and intense competition. Players come in all shapes and sizes in the National Hockey League (NHL), but some stand out as the toughest to play against. These individuals possess a unique combination of skills, physicality, and mental toughness, making them nightmares for their opponents. This article will look at the five toughest NHL players to play against, who have left an indelible mark on the game.

Zdeno Chara

Standing at a towering 6 feet 9 inches, Zdeno Chara is the tallest player in NHL history and one of the toughest. Known for his incredible reach and bone-crushing hits, Chara has made life difficult for countless opponents throughout his career. The Slovakian defenseman has been a force to be reckoned with in front of the net, blocking shots and clearing the crease with ease. His leadership and physical presence on the ice have made him one of the most feared players in the league. Chara’s intimidating demeanor and defensive prowess have earned him the respect of players and fans.

Tom Wilson

Tom Wilson of the Washington Capitals is a player with a knack for getting under the skin of his opponents. While he’s often regarded as one of the league’s most polarizing figures, there’s no denying his physicality and ability to change the course of a game. Wilson combines skill with a relentless work ethic, making him a threat on both ends of the ice. His willingness to drop the gloves and protect his teammates only adds to his reputation as a formidable player. Whether delivering bone-jarring hits or scoring crucial goals, Wilson’s presence is always felt on the ice.

Brad Marchand

Brad Marchand, a forward for the Boston Bruins, is another player who earns his spot on this list through a combination of skill and an aggressive playing style. Marchand is known for his agitating antics, often frustrating opponents and leading to penalties. However, beneath the pest-like exterior lies a highly skilled player capable of scoring goals and creating offensive opportunities. Marchand’s ability to get under the skin of his rivals while contributing offensively makes him a challenging adversary for any team.

Ryan Reaves

Currently, with the New York Rangers, Ryan Reaves has built a reputation as one of the NHL’s premier enforcers. Standing at 6 feet 2 inches and weighing over 225 pounds, Reaves is a physical force on the ice. He relishes the role of protector, defending his teammates with ferocious hits and intimidating presence. Reaves may not be known for scoring, but his impact on a game goes beyond the scoresheet. Opponents are always wary of his presence, knowing that a run-in with Reaves could lead to a painful experience.

Shea Weber

Shea Weber, the former captain of the Montreal Canadiens and now with the Nashville Predators, is a defenseman who strikes fear into the hearts of opposing forwards. Weber possesses one of the most challenging shots in the league, making him a formidable weapon on the power play. His ability to deliver bone-crushing hits and block shots with his body is unmatched. Weber’s leadership and ability to shut down opponents in crucial moments have made him a perennial Norris Trophy candidate. Facing Weber means contending with a defensive wall that is nearly impossible to breach.

These five players have made a lasting impact on the NHL, not only for their physical prowess but also for their ability to influence the outcome of games. While they may not always be the highest scorers, their presence on the ice looms large, creating an intimidation that affects their opponents’ decisions and performance. Whether through bone-rattling hits, defensive mastery, or agitating play, these players have earned their reputations as the toughest to play against.

The NHL has talented and competitive players, but these five individuals are the toughest to play against. Zdeno Chara, Tom Wilson, Brad Marchand, Ryan Reaves, and Shea Weber bring a unique combination of physicality, skill, and mental toughness to the ice. They are the players who can change the course of a game with a single hit or a clutch defensive play. For their opponents, facing these formidable adversaries is a daunting task that requires physical preparation and mental fortitude. These players embody what it means to be challenging in the NHL, and their legacies will endure in the annals of hockey history.



Richard M. Coleman

Richard Coleman worked at the Medical School of Harvard University in Boston, Massachusetts. Additionally, he worked at the Stanford University Medical School.